UK Gambling Policy Commission faces scrutiny over funding and remit

UK Gambling Policy Commission faces scrutiny over funding and remit

The new Gambling Policy Commission is drawing questions over its funding, accountability and lack of industry representation as UK white paper reforms remain in progress.

The newly formed Gambling Policy Commission (GPC) is facing questions from industry figures about its funding, accountability and purpose as it begins examining gambling policy in Great Britain. The debate comes while reforms in the government’s 2023 gambling white paper are still being implemented.

Established on Monday outside the statutory regulatory framework, the GPC has said it will review gambling policy. The Gambling Commission said it had not been told the group was being set up and stressed that it has no formal connection to the regulator.

Funding and accountability questioned

The GPC’s website says its seed funding was “philanthropically provided by Derek Webb”, a former professional poker player and founder of the Campaign for Fairer Gambling. Webb led the UK campaign to cut the maximum stake on gaming machines from £100 to £2 in 2018. He had not responded to a request for comment at the time of publication.

Dan Waugh, a consultant at Regulus Partners, called the commission “pretty bizarre” and questioned how many organisations backed by one US resident were seeking to influence UK gambling laws. He said Webb had also funded parliamentary groups, think tanks and campaign organisations, including the Gambling Reform APPG, Peers for Gambling Reform, the SMF, Bright Blue, Gambling with Lives and the Coalition to End Gambling Advertising.

Waugh contrasted the GPC with the Gambling Review Body chaired by Sir Alan Budd, which examined gambling laws in 2000–01 at the government’s request. The new group, he said, had no comparable mandate. Helen Walton, chief commercial officer and founder of G Gaming, said a government-commissioned review or select committee had built-in accountability, while a self-appointed commission risked adding pressure and confusion rather than evidence.

The panel is chaired by University of Cambridge economist Professor Jagjit Chadha OBE, with University of Reading professor James Reade as chief economist. Its eight members come from economics, law, public policy, health, academia and sport. Gibraltar gambling commissioner Andrew Lyman also questioned how evidence could be weighed objectively without industry representation.

White paper reforms remain a priority

Waugh argued that the Budd review addressed the balance between personal freedom and protection from harm, and said the new commission would need to recognise competing considerations to be taken seriously. Walton said a credible review should examine how recent policy, tax and affordability changes have affected licensed operators.

Waugh also questioned whether new legislation was needed so soon after the 2020–23 review, given the reforms remain in progress and existing powers could allow further changes. He suggested scrutiny of the Gambling Commission’s fitness and propriety might be more pressing.

Consultant Steve Donoughue criticised the regulator and called for industry-funded research and more public advocacy. Walton, by contrast, said the Gambling Commission was working with industry as well as overseeing it.

The regulator said the GPC is not a statutory body and has no role in regulating gambling in Great Britain. It said its priority was to complete and evaluate the white paper reforms. The Betting and Gaming Council likewise urged that the measures be given time to take effect and their impact be assessed.