Jurors in the trial of Cleveland Guardians pitcher Emmanuel Clase have seen footage of him socialising with friends as prosecutors presented evidence about wagers on alleged rigged pitches. The case centres on 18 pitches and charges that Clase and teammate Luis Ortiz took part in a scheme to influence games.
Video and bets on the Marte pitch
One clip shown in Brooklyn federal court featured Clase drinking Presidente and playing dominoes with friends at a table bearing a Boston Red Sox logo. In another, filmed at Citi Field in May 2023, Luis Arismendy Paca Mendez danced to the Backstreet Boys’ “I Want It That Way” as the Guardians played the New York Mets.
That night, Clase allegedly conspired to fix his first pitch in extra innings to former Mets outfielder Starling Marte. The 98.5-mile-per-hour cutter was called a ball. Several people in Clase’s circle allegedly wagered on whether the pitch would exceed 94.5 mph.
FBI Special Agent Ava Barnett testified that six DraftKings bets on the pitch ranged from several hundred dollars to $9,500, and all won. The group and people betting at its direction made about $27,000, she said. Luis Alberto de Aza Baez and Enoc Pena were among those in Clase’s circle. Pena, a cooperating witness who appears to have received immunity, allegedly won two bets on the pitch worth $5,538.40.
The trial began on 4 November and is scheduled to run into early December. Clase and Ortiz face charges including conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery and money laundering conspiracy. If convicted, each could face at least 20 years in federal prison. Robinson Vasquez, charged with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, is also a defendant. All three have pleaded not guilty.
Paca, a former Ohio roommate of Clase, faces charges including making false statements to the FBI. He is not a co-defendant and is being held without bail. Prosecutors have indicated they are unlikely to call Pena to testify. Defense lawyers have called him “uncredible” and accused him of lying on loan, tax and other financial forms.
Microbets and alleged code
Barnett also described 24 microbets placed on a 3 June 2023 pitch to Minnesota Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers. Clase’s slider bounced and struck catcher Mike Zunino. “It went straight into the ground and hit the catcher,” Barnett testified. The group wagered $11,671 and recorded net wins of $26,543.51, according to a government exhibit.
Prosecutors say references to roosters and chickens in messages between Clase and Pena were code for bets or pitches to be fixed. The defense argues the messages referred to the group’s cockfighting hobby, which it describes as part of Dominican Republic culture. Barnett testified about references to a “rooster” in the pit and “chicken number three”; court filings say Clase instructed someone to “play the third” after the first two were killed.
The trial has featured disputes over witness credibility, evidence and a prosecution motion concerning a statement from Vasquez. Testimony is due to resume Monday with government witness Jenner Olivo, a former housemate of Pena and Vasquez in Nantucket. Olivo testified that he understood Pena paid Paca for inside information on pitches.



